top of page

The Conspiracy Trap: When the Left and Right Start Thinking the Same Way

1 day ago
7 min read
Conspiracy theories and Critical Theory share a lens of suspicion. Christianity calls us to discernment grounded in God's truth.
Conspiracy theories and Critical Theory share a lens of suspicion. Christianity calls us to discernment grounded in God's truth.

I’m curious if you’ve noticed something happening lately in the Body of Christ, something rather ironic.


Many Christians are quick to reject Marxism and Critical Theory because of the way these systems interpret the world. They reduce enormous portions of human experience to struggles over power, separating people into categories of oppressors and oppressed. Conservatives, and particularly conservative Christians, have spent years pointing out the problems with viewing virtually every institution, relationship, and cultural disagreement through that lens.


But what if some Christians have unknowingly adopted a remarkably similar way of thinking?


Not from the political left, but through conspiracy culture.


Now, before we go any further, I’m not saying conspiracies don't exist. Of course they do. The Bible itself is filled with people conspiring to accomplish evil things. Joseph's brothers conspired against him. Absalom conspired against David. Haman plotted the destruction of the Jewish people. The religious leaders conspired to kill Jesus. More than forty men took an oath not to eat or drink until they had murdered Paul.


The Bible doesn't ask us to pretend powerful people never secretly work together to accomplish evil things. It explicitly tells us that they sometimes do.


The problem begins when conspiracy stops being an explanation for some events and becomes the lens through which we explain almost everything.

Different Villains, Similar Lens


Marxism understands history primarily through conflict between economic classes. Critical Theory and related intellectual traditions broadened the analysis of power into areas such as race, sex, culture, institutions, education, and language. These traditions are diverse, so they should not simply be collapsed into one philosophy, but a recurring theme is the examination of how power can operate through social structures and institutions.


Conspiratorial thinking can develop a surprisingly similar structure. The terminology changes, and the political conclusions may be completely different, but the basic narrative can look remarkably familiar:

  • There is a powerful group benefiting from the existing system.

  • Ordinary people are being manipulated or exploited.

  • Major institutions cannot be trusted because they serve those in power.

  • Most people don't realize what is happening.

  • A smaller group has awakened to what is really going on.

  • Evidence contradicting the narrative may itself be interpreted as part of the deception.

Marxism may speak of the bourgeoisie and proletariat. Critical approaches may focus on dominant and marginalized groups. Conspiracy culture talks about "the elites," "the establishment," "the Deep State," or whatever group happens to occupy the center of a particular theory.


The groups aren't the same. The philosophies aren't identical. But the temptation is similar, make hidden power the master explanation for reality.


Once that happens, suspicion becomes more than healthy skepticism. It becomes a worldview.


The Problem With a Worldview Built on Suspicion


There is an important difference between saying, "Powerful people sometimes conspire," and saying, "Powerful people are probably conspiring behind whatever I don't understand."


The first statement is historically undeniable. The second is an assumption. And assumptions are dangerous when they become unfalsifiable.


If evidence supports the conspiracy, that's proof. If evidence contradicts the conspiracy, that's proof the cover-up is working. If an expert agrees, he finally admitted the truth. If an expert disagrees, he's part of the system. If the media reports it, they're controlling the narrative. If the media doesn't report it, they're suppressing the story.


At that point, we've created a belief that can never be proven wrong because every possible outcome confirms it.


That isn't discernment. That's a closed system.


And Christians, of all people, should be extraordinarily cautious about adopting one.


Christianity Begins Somewhere Completely Different


Christianity doesn't begin by dividing humanity into oppressors and oppressed. It begins with something far more uncomfortable:

"For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God." — Romans 3:23

The fundamental human problem isn't that the wrong group controls the institutions. It isn't capitalism. It isn't socialism. It isn't government, corporations, universities, billionaires, media companies, Republicans, Democrats, conservatives, progressives, or some secret gathering of powerful people behind a locked door.


The fundamental problem is sin. And sin isn't confined to one social class.


It runs through all of them.


That means corruption can appear in governments, corporations, universities, churches, families, political movements, newsrooms, and the guy uploading a three-hour video from his basement explaining why everyone else has been deceived.


Christian anthropology leaves no room for believing that one group possesses all the corruption while another possesses all the righteousness.


No political movement has a monopoly on virtue.


No institution has a monopoly on corruption.


And no human being, including you and me, is exempt from the effects of sin.


But Christianity Actually Does Teach That Something Is Happening Behind the Scenes


Here is where the conversation gets particularly interesting.


Christianity absolutely teaches that there is an unseen conflict occurring behind what we can see.


Paul writes:

"For our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the authorities, against the cosmic powers of this darkness, against evil, spiritual forces in the heavens." — Ephesians 6:12

Scripture describes Satan as "the ruler of this world" (John 12:31) and "the god of this age" (2 Corinthians 4:4). John writes that "the whole world is under the sway of the evil one" (1 John 5:19).


So Christians should not adopt a purely materialistic understanding of history. There really is a principle of darkness operating within the world. There are spiritual forces opposed to God, His kingdom, His truth, and His people.


That's biblical Christianity. But here's the crucial distinction.


Scripture tells us that the spiritual enemy exists without teaching us that every human event can be traced to a secret earthly organization coordinating it.

Satan doesn't need a conference room.

Human beings already possess sinful hearts.


Sometimes evil results from deliberate coordination. Sometimes it results from greed. Sometimes pride. Sometimes cowardice. Sometimes incompetence. Sometimes people simply make terrible decisions. And sometimes multiple sinful people independently pursue their own interests and create something that looks coordinated because sin tends to produce predictable results.


The existence of spiritual warfare doesn't give Christians permission to invent earthly conspiracies for which we have no evidence.


Notice What Paul Tells Christians to Do


This may be the most revealing part of Ephesians 6.


After telling believers that invisible spiritual forces really are working against them, Paul doesn't tell them to uncover the conspiracy.


He tells them to:

  • stand firm,

  • put on the belt of truth,

  • wear the breastplate of righteousness,

  • carry the shield of faith,

  • wear the helmet of salvation,

  • wield the sword of the Spirit, which is the Word of God,

  • and pray.


That's fascinating.


Paul gives Christians one of the clearest descriptions of unseen spiritual warfare anywhere in Scripture, and his response isn't speculation.


It's faithfulness.


The Christian response to unseen evil isn't obsession with discovering everything happening behind the curtain. It's becoming the kind of person who cannot easily be manipulated by what comes through the curtain.


Discernment Is Not Cynicism


Christians shouldn't be naïve.


Governments sometimes lie. Corporations sometimes deceive. News organizations sometimes get stories wrong or present information selectively. Scientists can have biases. Pastors can abuse authority. Intelligence agencies can exceed their authority. Political leaders can manipulate information.


History gives us documented examples of all of these things.


But recognizing that institutions can lie is very different from assuming that institutions are always lying.


Scripture never commands cynicism. It commands discernment. And there's an enormous difference.


Cynicism begins by assuming deception. Discernment begins by testing a claim.

Paul tells believers, "Test all things. Hold on to what is good" (1 Thessalonians 5:21). The Mosaic Law required multiple witnesses before serious accusations could be established. Exodus warns against spreading false reports. The ninth commandment forbids bearing false witness. Paul tells believers in Philippians 4:8 to dwell upon whatever is true.


Notice the consistent principle. Truth comes first.


Not suspicion.


Not institutional authority.


Not distrust of institutional authority.


Truth.


Christians Should Be the Hardest People in the World to Deceive


That leads me to something I think Christians desperately need to recover:

Christians should be the hardest people in the world to deceive—not because we assume everyone is lying, but because we know where ultimate truth is found.

We shouldn't automatically believe something because CNN said it.


We shouldn't automatically reject it because CNN said it.


We shouldn't automatically believe something because the government announced it.


We shouldn't automatically reject it because the government announced it.


And we certainly shouldn't automatically believe something because a guy on social media begins his video with, "They're not going to tell you this..."


The source doesn't determine truth.

Truth determines whether the source is trustworthy.

That means Christians should examine evidence, seek corroboration, distinguish facts from speculation, recognize what we don't know, and, perhaps most importantly, be willing to say three words that conspiracy culture doesn't particularly reward, "I don't know."


There is humility in those words.


We Already Know Who Is Behind the Darkness


Christianity doesn't require us to pretend there isn't something happening behind the scenes.


There is.


Scripture has already told us.


There is a kingdom of darkness opposed to the kingdom of God. Satan deceives. Sin corrupts. Human beings seek power. Governments can become wicked. Institutions can become corrupt. People can conspire.


But none of this should surprise the Christian. And none of it should consume us.


Our mission was never to uncover every secret operation occurring in the world. Jesus didn't commission His disciples to expose every conspiracy. He commissioned them to make disciples.


Our hope isn't that eventually someone will release the documents.


Our hope isn't that the right whistleblower will finally come forward.


Our hope isn't that someday everyone will wake up and realize we've been right all along.


Our hope is Jesus Christ.


We Don't Need Secret Knowledge. We Have Revealed Truth.


That's ultimately where conspiracy culture and Christianity part company.


Conspiracy culture constantly promises another layer of secret knowledge. There's always another revelation coming, another hidden connection to discover, another person behind the person behind the person who supposedly controls everything.


Christianity points us in the opposite direction. God has revealed what we actually need to know.


We know humanity's problem.


We know who our enemy is.


We know where deception originates.


We know who conquered sin and death.


And we know how the story ends.


So yes, Christians should question claims. We should investigate evidence. We should expose genuine corruption when we encounter it. We should hold leaders accountable. And when actual conspiracies are demonstrated by evidence, we shouldn't be afraid to call them conspiracies.


But we should never allow suspicion to become our worldview. Because the goal of the Christian life isn't to become impossible to fool because we've uncovered every secret.


It's to become difficult to deceive because we've been grounded in the truth of God's Word.

Comments


Contact us!

Thanks for submitting!

2024 Revolver Broadcasting. All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page