LAWFARE AND POLITICAL POWEr Research Paper - Op Eds to Follow
A Comparative Evidence Audit of Six Modern American Cases
An Embers of Truth Research Project with Darmak
The Facts • The Disputes • The Open Questions
“And the light shineth in darkness; and the darkness comprehended it not.” John 1:5 • KJV

Contents
Executive Summary
I. Definition and Evidentiary Standard
II. Methodology and Source Balance
Author Note and AI Research Disclosure
III. Carter Page FISA and Crossfire Hurricane
IV. IRS Tax-Exempt Screening
V. Operation Choke Point
VI. Standard & Poor’s
VII. Jack Smith, Arctic Frost, and the Federal Election Case
VIII. Manhattan Business-Records Prosecution
IX. Rejected and Qualified Cases
X. Cross-Case Comparison
XI. Overall Findings
XII. Update Notes for Later Editions
Publication Status and Limitations
Research Record and Audit Files
XIII. Manhattan Appellate Status at Research Cutoff
Executive summary
The central conclusion of this study is narrower than the strongest partisan claims but more serious than the claim that every controversy was ordinary law enforcement. Across the six principal cases, the evidence shows recurring failures or disputes involving surveillance accuracy, viewpoint-sensitive administration, informal regulatory leverage, selective or retaliatory enforcement theories, investigative breadth, privilege safeguards, and unusually consequential prosecutorial discretion. Yet the record does not establish one centrally
directed conspiracy spanning administrations, agencies, and jurisdictions.
The analysis therefore treats lawfare as a spectrum of governmental process rather than a synonym for prosecution. A case becomes stronger when independent evidence shows that legal power was applied selectively, irregularly, disproportionately, retaliatorily, or in a manner that burdened protected political activity. A legitimate predicate does not excuse abusive process. Likewise, an aggressive or novel legal theory does not by itself prove political punishment.
On the present record, the strongest process-lawfare cases are the Carter Page FISA process and IRS tax-exempt screening. Operation Choke Point and Standard & Poor’s present substantial but more qualified evidence. The Jack Smith/Arctic Frost matter presents a strong investigative-process concern alongside a substantial underlying election-investigation predicate. The Manhattan business-records prosecution remains expressly provisional because a unanimous conviction stands while significant issues remain under direct appellate review.
I. Definition and evidentiary standard
For this paper, “lawfare” means the use of legal, investigative, regulatory, judicial, or
administrative power in a manner that is materially shaped by a purpose to punish, burden, intimidate, selectively disadvantage, or politically disable an opponent or disfavored group, or by procedures so irregular and rights-burdening that they create a strong process centered lawfare concern. Mere disagreement over legal authority is not enough. Four evidentiary levels are used. Level 1 identifies political controversy without sufficient proof of irregular use of power. Level 2 identifies a credible concern supported by specific irregularities, disparate treatment, unusual pressure, or disproportionate methods. Level 3 identifies strong process-lawfare evidence validated by primary records, courts, inspectors general, or similarly weighty evidence. Level 4 would require direct, reliable proof that legal
power was intentionally deployed principally for political punishment or disablement. None of the six principal cases is placed at Level 4 on the present record.
The methodology deliberately separates five questions: whether a legitimate predicate existed; whether the challenged procedure was unusual or improper; whether similarly situated comparators were treated differently; whether political motive can be established; and whether an independent institution validated or rejected the claim. This prevents legitimate government objectives from being used to excuse abusive methods and prevents political controversy from being mistaken for proof of retaliatory motive.
II. Methodology and source balance
Primary materials receive the greatest weight: court opinions and dockets, inspector-general reports, agency records, settlement agreements, warrants, affidavits, congressional document releases, and official statements. Ideological commentary is used mainly to identify competing theories or overlooked evidence, not as a substitute for primary proof.
For politically contested claims, the research deliberately tests conservative and right
leaning allegations against government records, mainstream reporting, center-left or prosecution-supporting analysis, and contrary primary evidence. The reverse is also true: official or mainstream characterizations are not treated as dispositive where primary records or contrary oversight evidence materially complicate them.
A major credibility control is the inclusion of negative-control cases. Investigations involving Gibson Guitar, Dinesh D’Souza, Nakoula Basseley Nakoula, and other controversial matters were not elevated to the final six merely because critics described them as lawfare. Those cases illustrate that admitted offenses, legitimate predicates, failed selective-prosecution claims, or weak comparator evidence can keep a politically controversial case below the final threshold.
Author Note and AI Research Disclosure
About the Author
I am not an attorney or legal scholar, and nothing in this paper should be understood as legal advice. I approach this subject as an interested citizen and an amateur historian who has spent years studying American history, politics, constitutional issues, and the use of government power. My goal is not to pretend to expertise I do not have. It is to examine the available record carefully, present competing arguments fairly, document the sources so readers can check the evidence themselves, and then explain where I believe that evidence
leads.
AI Research Disclosure
Artificial intelligence was used as a research, organizational, drafting, and document
production assistant in the development of this project. Microsoft 365 Copilot was used to help identify research leads, organize source material, compare competing claims, develop case-study structures, draft and revise explanatory text, and prepare working documents and presentation materials.
AI-generated statements were not treated as primary evidence. The project’s factual and legal claims were repeatedly checked against cited court records, inspector-general reports, government documents, official transcripts, filings, settlement materials, and reporting or commentary representing competing political and legal perspectives. When the available record did not establish a claim, the project attempts to identify that limitation rather than present an inference as fact.
The use of AI does not make the research error-free. AI systems can misunderstand sources, omit relevant context, repeat an error found in secondary reporting, or generate inaccurate citations. For that reason, this project maintains a source-first methodology and a separate claim-by-claim audit process. Primary documents receive the greatest evidentiary weight; partisan and ideological sources are used to identify arguments and evidence that must then be tested against the underlying record.
I selected the subject, research questions, standards, case studies, editorial direction, and final arguments. AI assisted the research and writing process; it is not presented as an independent authority or as a substitute for the cited evidence. Final responsibility for the judgments and conclusions belongs to me as the author.
Editorial Standard
The governing rule of this project is the same regardless of political party: a legitimate legal predicate does not excuse abusive process, and a controversial or unsuccessful legal action does not by itself prove lawfare. Allegations, documented facts, disputed interpretations, and my conclusions are therefore kept separate whenever the record allows.
III. Carter Page FISA and Crossfire Hurricane
Classification: Level 3 — strong process-lawfare evidence
The underlying Crossfire Hurricane investigation cannot responsibly be described as wholly fabricated. The Justice Department Inspector General concluded that the information available when the investigation opened satisfied the FBI’s low predication threshold and reported no documentary or testimonial evidence that political bias caused the opening. (1)
The Carter Page FISA process is materially different. The inspector-general record identified numerous significant inaccuracies and omissions across the four applications and renewals. Information undermining or qualifying the government’s presentation was not consistently supplied to decision makers or the FISA Court, and the later record included the criminal case involving Kevin Clinesmith’s alteration of an email. (2)
The strongest lawfare finding therefore concerns the surveillance process, accuracy
obligations, renewal decisions, and institutional safeguards rather than a claim that the entire Russia investigation lacked any predicate. That distinction is essential because it separates a defensible finding of process abuse from a broader conspiracy claim not established by the reviewed evidence. (3)
(1) U.S. Department of Justice, Office of the Inspector General, Review of Four FISA Applications and Other Aspects of the FBI’s Crossfire Hurricane Investigation, Report No. 20-012 (Dec. 2019), Executive Summary at iii–iv; ch. 3, “The Opening of Crossfire Hurricane and Four Related Investigations,” pp. 49–70, Https://oig.justice.gov/sites/default/files/reports/20-012.PDF
(2) DOJ OIG, Review of Four FISA Applications, Executive Summary at vi–xiii; chs. 5–8, especially ch. 5, “The Carter Page FISA Applications,” and ch. 8, “Accuracy and Completeness,” pp. 127–357, https://oig.justice.gov/sites/default/files/reports/20-012.PDF
(3) U.S. Attorney’s Office, District of Connecticut, “FBI Attorney Admits Altering Email Used for FISA Application During ‘Crossfire Hurricane’ Investigation” (Aug. 19, 2020), paragraphs beginning “According to court documents” through the description of the fourth FISA application, https://www.justice.gov/usao-ct/pr/fbi-attorney-admits-altering-email-used-fisa
application-during-crossfire-hurricane.
IV. IRS tax-exempt screening
Classification: Level 3 — strong administrative/selective-treatment evidence
TIGTA determined that inappropriate criteria were used to identify applications for additional review and documented delays and unnecessary information requests. The strongest comparator evidence from the core audited period showed materially different referral patterns for specified conservative-name categories and specified progressive-name categories. (4)
The broader historical record prevents the paper from claiming that only conservative or 4right-leaning organizations were ever subjected to questionable ideological or issue-based criteria. Likewise, the evidence reviewed did not establish White House direction or a prosecutable partisan conspiracy. (5)
The case nevertheless remains one of the strongest because improper viewpoint-sensitive criteria and selective administrative burdens were independently documented. It demonstrates that lawfare concerns can involve tax administration and bureaucratic delay rather than criminal prosecution.
(4) Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration, Inappropriate Criteria Were Used to Identify Tax-Exempt Applications for Review, Ref. No. 2013-10-053 (May 14, 2013), Highlights, “What TIGTA Found”; Results of Review, pp. 5–17, Https://oversight.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/201310053fr-revised-redacted-1.pdf.
(5) Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration, Review of Selected Criteria Used to
Identify Tax-Exempt Applications for Review, Ref. No. 2017-10-054 (Sept. 28, 2017), Highlights, “Why TIGTA Did the Audit” and “What TIGTA Found”; Results of Review, pp. 3–10, https://www.tigta.gov/sites/default/files/reports/2022-02/201710054fr.pdf.
V. Operation Choke Point
Classification: Level 2–3 — credible regulatory-coercion case
The legitimate side of Operation Choke Point must remain visible. DOJ pursued actual fraud cases involving banks, processors, and unauthorized withdrawals, and the FDIC OIG concluded that FDIC participation in DOJ’s initiative was limited while its general supervision of higher-risk banking relationships fell within its authority. (6)
The concern arises from informal supervisory leverage. The OIG found communications inconsistent with written FDIC policy and guidance and documented strongly negative official attitudes toward payday lending that could influence staff behavior. Those findings support a process-centered concern that regulated banks could receive powerful informal signals about lawful customers even without a formal prohibition. (7)
The evidence is strongest for payday lending and weaker for broad claims that every firearms or ammunition business losing banking access was directly debanked by
government order. The most defensible conclusion is therefore one of credible informal coercion, not proof that every Choke Point enforcement action was political persecution.
(6) Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Office of Inspector General, The FDIC’s Role in Operation Choke Point and Supervisory Approach to Institutions that Conducted Business with Merchants Associated with High-Risk Activities, Report No. AUD-15-008 (Sept. 2015), Executive Summary, “Results of Audit,” pp. ii–iv; “The FDIC’s Role in Operation Choke Point,” pp. 5–9, https://www.fdicoig.gov/sites/default/files/reports/2022-08/15-008AUD.pdf.
7FDIC OIG, The FDIC’s Role in Operation Choke Point, Report No. AUD-15-008, “Supervisory Approach to Institutions That Conducted Business with High-Risk Merchants,” pp. 9–20, and “Corporation Comments and OIG Evaluation,” pp. 21–23,
VI. Standard & Poor’s
Classification: Level 2–3 — serious selective/retaliatory-enforcement concern
DOJ brought a substantial civil action concerning pre-financial-crisis ratings of mortgage related securities. The case concluded in a $1.375 billion government/state settlement, but S&P’s own announcement stated that the settlement contained no findings of violations of law. DOJ separately stated that S&P acknowledged specified conduct in an agreed statement of facts. (8)
The retaliation issue became unusually significant because S&P’s claim that the federal case followed its downgrade of U.S. sovereign credit advanced beyond public accusation. A federal court found enough preliminary evidence concerning discriminatory effect and purpose to permit selective-prosecution discovery. That was a discovery-stage ruling, not a final merits determination. (9)
The case settled before the retaliation theory reached final adjudication, and S&P retracted the retaliation allegation as part of the settlement. The case therefore shows why a substantial underlying enforcement claim and a serious possible-retaliation theory are not mutually exclusive. (10)
(8) U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Public Affairs, “Justice Department and State Partners Secure $1.375 Billion Settlement with S&P for Defrauding Investors in the Lead Up to the Financial Crisis” (Feb. 3, 2015), paragraphs 2–5 under the opening announcement (settlement amount, agreed statement of facts, and retraction), https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/justice-department-and-state-partners-secure-1375 billion-settlement-sp-defrauding-investors.
(9) United States v. McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., No. CV 13-0779-DOC (JCGx) (C.D. Cal.), Order Denying Motion for Phased Trials and Partially Granting Motion to Compel Discovery, Dkt. 166 (Apr. 15, 2014), pp. 16–20 (finding that S&P had presented “some evidence tending to show” discriminatory effect and discriminatory purpose and ordering selective-prosecution discovery); Order Partially Granting Motions to Compel Discovery, Dkts. 273 & 274 (Sept. 24, 2014), pp. 2–3 (recounting Dkt. 166 and its pp. 16–20 finding), https://business.cch.com/srd/US-v-McGrawHill092514.pdf.
(10) DOJ, “Justice Department and State Partners Secure $1.375 Billion Settlement with S&P” (Feb. 3, 2015), paragraph 4 (S&P’s formal retraction of its retaliation allegation), https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/justice-department-and-state-partners-secure-1375 billion-settlement-sp-defrauding-investors.
VII. Jack Smith, Arctic Frost, and the Federal Election Case
Classification: Level 3 - strong process-lawfare evidence with substantial evidence of political selectivity
The federal election investigation had a substantial factual predicate. Alternate-elector documents and certification evidence justified investigation of conduct beyond protected political speech, recounts, audits, and election litigation. The existence of that predicate is an important counterweight to claims that the investigation was invented from nothing. But a legitimate predicate does not answer whether an investigation later became disproportionate, politically selective, or excessively intrusive. (11)
That distinction has become central as the Arctic Frost record has emerged. Senate Judiciary Committee disclosures report that Jack Smith's Special Counsel Office and the Justice Department obtained information associated with at least 639,000 Republican donors, voters, and supporters. The reported data included names, dates of birth, addresses, email addresses, Republican-registration information, occupations and employers, legislative districts, contribution amounts, partial credit-card information, and donor-analysis data. The earliest contribution captured reportedly dated to 2005. (12)
The collection extended beyond major organizations and people suspected of direct participation in election-related conduct. Committee records state that investigators obtained information concerning Trump campaign personnel, a catalogue of campaign products, and sales of red MAGA hats, including individual purchasers, products purchased, and shipping addresses.12 Separate disclosures report that Smith's team acquired at least 4,782 checks from Americans who made
mainly small-dollar donations to Trump or Trump-aligned Republican entities. The checks reportedly exposed home addresses, bank-account and routing numbers, and signatures. (13)
Congressional records create an additional separation-of-powers concern. Committee oversight identified telecommunications subpoenas seeking toll records for current or former Republican members of Congress. The disclosed
records concerned metadata rather than call content, an important limitation. But released internal records also show investigators discussing possible Speech or Debate Clause protections while considering collection involving lawmakers. (14)
These disclosures establish more than incidental contact with Republicans. They show investigative collection reaching Republican lawmakers, organizations, donors, voters, supporters, campaign personnel, and political-merchandise
purchasers. That does not prove every person appearing in a subpoena return was a criminal target. Nor does the reviewed record establish that President Joe Biden personally ordered the prosecution or directed individual investigative steps. The
Senate committee's conclusions about partisan purpose remain attributed oversight findings unless independently established.
Motive and political selectivity, however, are not identical. The one-party concentration of the disclosed collection is itself relevant evidence. When a criminal investigation reaches deeply into the personal information and protected political activity of ordinary Americans identified through support for one political movement, the government bears an especially heavy burden to establish relevance, proportionality, minimization, and constitutional safeguards.
The legal case also encountered important limits. The Supreme Court narrowed the federal obstruction statute used in January 6 prosecutions and recognized substantial presidential immunity for official acts. Those decisions did not establish
partisan motive, but they confirmed that important parts of the surrounding statutory and constitutional framework were narrower than the government had argued. (15)
The strongest conclusion lies between two partisan absolutes. Arctic Frost cannot responsibly be described as an investigation created from nothing. But neither can it now be treated as ordinary law enforcement merely because an initial
predicate existed. The extraordinary breadth of collection involving Republican political networks, lawmakers, donors, supporters, and merchandise purchasers, together with unresolved privilege and proportionality questions, satisfies this paper's Level 3 standard.
The reviewed record does not yet supply the direct proof required for Level 4: reliable evidence that legal power was intentionally deployed principally to punish or politically disable Republicans or Donald Trump. But political selectivity is
documented strongly enough that partisan purpose cannot fairly be dismissed as speculation. A legitimate predicate did not give investigators a blank check.
Arctic Frost therefore receives one overall classification: Level 3 - strong process-lawfare evidence with substantial evidence of political selectivity, but without the direct proof of principally punitive partisan purpose required for Level 4.
Updated footnotes
(11) Jack Smith, Special Counsel, Final Report on the Special Counsel's Investigations and Prosecutions, vol. 1 (Jan. 7, 2025), transmittal letter and Executive Summary, pp. 1-11; U.S. Department of Justice, archived Special Counsel materials.
(12) U.S. Senate Committee on the Judiciary majority, "Grassley Shares Explosive Arctic Frost Update Revealing Jack Smith Obtained Treasure Trove of Data for Over Half a Million Republican Supporters" (Oct. 14, 2026), including accompanying investigative memorandum and subpoena-return descriptions. The committee's statements about motive are attributed conclusions rather than judicial findings.
(13) U.S. Senate Committee on the Judiciary majority, "Jack Smith's Team Collected Checks from Nearly 5,000 Americans in All 50 States" (Sept. 29, 2026), reporting 4,782 checks and the categories of personal and banking information visible on them.
(14) U.S. Senate Committee on the Judiciary majority, Arctic Frost telecommunications oversight releases (Feb. 10 and Mar. 24, 2026), including records concerning congressional tolling data and internal recognition of possible Speech or Debate Clause protections. Toll records are metadata, not call content.
(15) Fischer v. United States, 603 U.S. ___ (2024), slip op.; Trump v. United States, 603 U.S. 593 (2024), slip op.
VIII. Manhattan Business-Records Prosecution
Classification: Level 2-3 - strong but expressly provisional concern
The Manhattan prosecution presents two facts that must be held together. A New York jury convicted Donald Trump on all 34 counts of falsifying business records in the first degree. That verdict is substantial counterevidence to claims that prosecutors invented the underlying records or presented no supporting evidence. (16)
But the lawfare question is broader than whether the records existed. The stronger concern is how an established business-records statute was used to construct an unusual felony prosecution of a former president and leading presidential candidate. The felony theory depended on intent to commit, aid, or conceal another crime and on a layered relationship among business records, New York Election Law section 17-152, federal election law, other records, and tax law. (17)
The jury instructions deepen the concern. Jurors had to agree unanimously that Trump conspired to promote or prevent an election by unlawful means, but they were instructed that they did not have to agree unanimously about which alleged unlawful means occurred. The possible means included Federal Election Campaign Act violations, falsification of other business records, and tax-law violations. (18)
Critics argue that this framework allowed agreement that some unlawful means existed while permitting disagreement over the legal violation supplying it, raising a Sixth Amendment unanimity concern. Supporters respond that unanimity was required as to the election conspiracy, not the particular means. No controlling appellate decision reviewed for this edition has invalidated the instruction, so the paper treats the issue as a substantial unresolved process concern rather than a settled constitutional violation. (18)
Presidential immunity adds a separate unresolved issue. Federal removal litigation has considered the significance of evidence allegedly involving official presidential acts. The Second Circuit vacated the denial of leave to file a second removal notice and remanded for reconsideration without directing the ultimate result. That proceeding remains distinct from the direct state appeal. (19)
The cumulative record includes unusual felony architecture, consequential prosecutorial discretion, a disputed jury-unanimity framework, unresolved immunity questions, and prosecution of a former president and active candidate in an extraordinary political environment. Against those concerns stands the unanimous 34-count verdict. Under this paper's standard, the cumulative record supports Level 3 - strong prosecutorial-process lawfare evidence. The
evidence does not establish the Level 4 proposition that legal power was demonstrably deployed principally for political punishment, nor does it establish that President Joe Biden directed the prosecution.
16 Supreme Court of the State of New York, People v. Donald J. Trump, Verdict Sheet, Indictment No. 71543-23 (May 30, 2024), pp. 1-3; New York State Unified Court System official case repository.
17 Supreme Court of the State of New York, People v. Donald J. Trump, Post-Summation Instructions (May 29, 2024), including the elements of Penal Law section 175.10 and Election Law section 17-152.
18 People v. Donald J. Trump, Post-Summation Instructions, pp. 30-31; Seth Barrett Tillman, “The Right to a Unanimous Verdict and the Jury Instructions in People v. Trump,” Just Security (June 10, 2024). The constitutional criticism is an analytical position, not a final appellate ruling.
19 Brief for Defendant-Appellant, People v. Trump, App. Div. 1st Dep't Case No. 2025-00648; New York v. Trump, No. 24-2299-cv, 158 F.4th 458 (2d Cir. Nov. 6, (2025), vacating and remanding the removal ruling; subsequent federal proceedings. The state direct appeal and federal removal litigation are separate matters.
IX. Overall Findings
The six strongest cases do not prove one centrally directed conspiracy. They reveal recurring institutional vulnerabilities. Arctic Frost and Manhattan are both classified at Level 3, but for different forms of process-centered lawfare. Arctic Frost is primarily about investigative breadth, political selectivity, donor and supporter information, congressional records, privilege, and proportionality. Manhattan is primarily about prosecutorial discretion, unusual felony architecture, the
disputed unanimity framework, immunity questions, and extraordinary political context.
A legitimate predicate, judicial authorization, or conviction is important counterevidence, but none automatically resolves a process-lawfare claim. Conversely, novelty, reversal, political timing, or controversy alone does not prove punitive motive.
XII. Update Notes for Later Editions
Manhattan: incorporate the First Department merits ruling when issued and any further federal removal decision. Keep the
direct state appeal separate from federal removal litigation.
Arctic Frost: incorporate complete subpoena schedules, return inventories, privilege logs, comparator evidence, and any
judicial or inspector-general ruling.
It is a historical and public-affairs research project,
not legal advice or a judicial finding. Characterizations supplied by courts, agencies, committees, litigants, or commentators are
attributed rather than adopted as independently proved.
X. Manhattan Appellate Status at Research Cutoff
As of the research cutoff, the New York Appellate Division, First Department had heard argument but the reviewed sources did not report a merits decision. The conviction therefore remained in place subject to direct state appellate review. (19)
The separate federal removal track raised overlapping but distinct questions. The Second Circuit vacated the denial of leave to file a second notice of removal and remanded for reconsideration without prescribing the final result. (19)
19 Brief for Defendant-Appellant, People v. Trump, App. Div. 1st Dep't Case No. 2025-00648; New York v. Trump, No. 24-2299-cv, 158 F.4th 458 (2d Cir. Nov. 6, (2025), vacating and remanding the removal ruling; subsequent federal proceedings. The state direct appeal and federal removal litigation are separate matters.
.png)


Comments