top of page

When the IRS Put Politics in the Screening Room

4 days ago
5 min read

By Jim Davis (Darmak)

Embers of Truth | Lawfare and Political Power


IRS - Weaponized
IRS - Weaponized

Imagine you are part of a group of ordinary Americans who decide they want to become more involved in their government. You organize, fill out the paperwork, send an application to the IRS for tax-exempt status, and wait. Then the questions begin. More paperwork is requested. More information is demanded. Months go by, and your application still isn’t moving. All the while, somewhere inside the federal government, words associated with your political beliefs are being used to help determine whether your application deserves additional scrutiny.


That is what makes the IRS controversy so important to this lawfare project. When we hear the word “lawfare,” we tend to think about prosecutors, indictments, judges and courtrooms. But the government doesn’t have to prosecute someone to use its enormous power against them. It can investigate you, audit you, regulate you, demand records from you or simply bury you in a bureaucratic process that seems to have no end.


That matters because a political organization depends on time, money, volunteers and the ability to participate in the public debate. If government makes that participation more difficult because of what an organization believes, we have a serious problem whether anyone is ever charged with a crime or not. The Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration’s investigation concluded that the IRS had used inappropriate criteria to identify certain applications for additional scrutiny. The investigation also documented substantial delays and unnecessary information requests. Those weren’t accusations coming from a political campaign. They were findings from the government’s own watchdog.


But this is also where I think we have to be careful. From the beginning, the purpose of the Embers of Truth project has not been to prove what we already believe. The purpose is to follow the evidence wherever it takes us. If evidence supports our argument, we include it. If evidence makes our argument harder, we include that too. Otherwise this isn’t research. It is advocacy disguised as research.


The evidence raises serious questions about the treatment of conservative-associated organizations during the central period of this controversy. At the same time, a later inspector general review found questionable screening criteria involving other kinds of organizations as well. That means I am not going to tell you that every questionable IRS screening practice was directed only at conservatives, because the record does not justify saying that.


But that doesn’t make the underlying problem disappear.


We also did not establish that Barack Obama personally ordered the targeting or that the White House directed a criminal conspiracy. Some readers may want me to go further than that, but I won’t. If the evidence doesn’t prove something, we shouldn’t pretend that it does. That same standard has to apply whether the person sitting in the White House is a Democrat or a Republican.


Here is the other side of that argument, though, and I think it is extremely important. We don’t have to prove that the President personally gave an order before becoming concerned about the government treating citizens differently because of their political or ideological beliefs. If political considerations entered a government process that was supposed to be administered neutrally, that by itself should concern us.


This is where partisan politics can get in the way of common sense. One side wants the IRS controversy to prove a conspiracy reaching all the way into the White House. The other side seems to suggest that if you cannot prove that conspiracy, there wasn’t much of a scandal at all. I don’t accept either choice. The more important question is much simpler: Did political or ideological considerations enter a government process where they did not belong?


If they did, Americans should care. We should care whether the people being scrutinized are conservative or liberal, Republican or Democrat. The IRS has enormous power over ordinary Americans. Most citizens don’t have anything close to the resources of the federal government, and that imbalance of power is exactly why political neutrality is so important.


There is a simple way to test whether we really believe that principle: reverse the parties. Imagine a Republican administration where progressive organizations were being pulled aside because IRS employees were using words associated with the political left to identify applications for additional scrutiny. Imagine those organizations waiting month after month while being asked for additional information. Would Democrats be satisfied if Republicans simply said, “You can’t prove the President personally ordered it”? Of course they wouldn’t, and frankly, they shouldn’t be.


Conservatives should apply exactly the same standard. The principle cannot change depending upon whose ox is being gored. If something is an abuse of government power when Democrats do it, it has to be an abuse of power when Republicans do it. If our definition changes depending upon which political party benefits, then we aren’t defending a constitutional principle. We’re defending a team.


So what does the IRS case actually prove? It doesn’t prove that every IRS employee involved was motivated by partisan politics. It doesn’t establish a White House conspiracy, and it doesn’t show that every questionable screening criterion was directed only at conservatives. But what it does show is serious enough. The government’s own watchdog found inappropriate criteria, delays and unnecessary information requests. The record raises substantial concerns about political or ideological considerations entering an administrative process where they never should have been.


That is why, based on the evidence we examined, I place the IRS case at Level 3: strong evidence of administrative or selective-treatment lawfare. I don’t reach that conclusion because every accusation made about the IRS controversy was proved. They weren’t. I reach it because we don’t need the biggest accusation to recognize the underlying danger.


And in the end, I don’t think the biggest lesson here is really about Barack Obama. It is about government power. Presidents leave office. Political parties lose elections. Administrations change. But the powers we give the government don’t disappear when our side loses an election. Those powers are still there, waiting for the next group of people who take control.


Government has the right to enforce legitimate laws. It has the authority to investigate wrongdoing and require people and organizations to follow the rules. But an American’s political beliefs cannot become part of the price he pays for dealing with his own government.


So forget for a moment whether you like the Tea Party, Barack Obama, the IRS or any particular political movement. Ask yourself one question: If the government knows what you believe, should that change how the government treats you?

My answer is no. And I hope, no matter which side of the political aisle you are on, yours is too.


This political lawfare should not be happening under any administration, at any time. To date, there has been minimal accountability for those who have weaponized the government, and when accountability is pursued, too often it is immediately called lawfare itself. We are in danger of losing sight of our Constitutional Republic, not simply a democracy, because of the never-ending quest for more political power. We have seen former presidents attacked along with members of their administrations, and this cycle must end. Those who abuse government power should be investigated, held accountable, and, when the evidence proves they knowingly violated criminal law, prosecuted and punished according to law, including imprisonment when warranted. It doesn’t matter to me who does it or what political party they belong to. The standard has to be the same for everyone. No one should be above the law, but neither should the law ever be used as a political weapon.


EMBERS OF TRUTH

The facts. The disputes. The open questions.

Recent Posts

See All
WHEN DOES JUSTICE BECOME LAWFARE?

Before We Accuse Anyone of Weaponizing the Law, We Ought to Be Able to Prove It By Jim Davis | Embers of Truth Imagine two Americans watching the same courthouse steps. One sees justice. The other see

 
 
 

Comments


Contact us!

Thanks for submitting!

2024 Revolver Broadcasting. All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page