top of page

WHEN DOES JUSTICE BECOME LAWFARE?

Nov 14
5 min read

Before We Accuse Anyone of Weaponizing the Law, We Ought to Be Able to Prove It


By Jim Davis | Embers of Truth



Imagine two Americans watching the same courthouse steps.


One sees justice. The other sees political persecution.


One hears that a prosecutor has indicted a former president and says, “Nobody is above the law.” The other looks at the timing, the prosecutor, the legal theory and the political consequences and asks, “Would this case ever have been brought against anyone else?”


That divide is where this project began. Not with Donald Trump. Not with Democrats or Republicans. With a question:


When does the legitimate exercise of legal power become the political weaponization of the law?


We use the word lawfare constantly now. Conservatives use it to describe prosecutions of Donald Trump. Progressives often dismiss the term as an excuse politicians use when they do not like being held accountable. Both answers are too easy.


If we are going to accuse prosecutors, investigators, regulators or other government officials of using legal power to punish political opponents, we ought to be able to prove it. And if someone tells us an action cannot be lawfare simply because prosecutors followed legal procedures, we ought to demand proof of that too.


That is the standard of this investigation.


Disagreement Is Not Lawfare


A president being sued is not automatically lawfare. A politician being investigated is not automatically lawfare. A prosecutor bringing charges against a political figure is not automatically lawfare. A judge ruling against a president is not automatically judicial activism. And an appellate court reversing that judge does not automatically prove the lower court acted politically. America’s constitutional system was built around conflict. Presidents test the limits of executive power. Congress pushes back. States challenge Washington. Citizens sue their government. Prosecutors investigate suspected crimes. Courts decide what statutes mean.


A disagreement over who has the legal or constitutional power to do something is not lawfare simply because one side loses.


Lawfare requires something more.


So What Is Lawfare?


For this project, lawfare occurs when legal, investigative, regulatory, judicial or administrative power becomes materially shaped by a purpose to punish, burden, intimidate, selectively disadvantage or politically disable an opponent or disfavored group, or when the procedures become so irregular and rights-burdening that the process itself creates a serious lawfare concern.


That definition intentionally sets the bar high. Because a legitimate reason to begin an investigation does not give the government permission to do anything it wants afterward.


A legitimate predicate is not a blank check.


An investigation can begin legitimately and later become abusive. A prosecution can involve real evidence and still employ troubling legal theories. An enforcement action can address genuine misconduct and still raise questions about selective enforcement. Those ideas can exist at the same time.


Follow the Evidence, Not the Party


I cannot use one evidentiary standard when the defendant is Donald Trump and another when the target is someone I oppose politically. So I built a four-level scale.


Level 1 means political controversy without sufficient evidence that government power was used irregularly. Level 2 means a credible lawfare concern supported by unusual pressure, disparate treatment, questionable procedures or disproportionate methods. Level 3 means primary records, courts, inspectors general or similarly authoritative evidence supports serious concerns about government process. Level 4 requires direct, reliable proof that legal power was intentionally deployed principally to punish or politically disable an opponent.


Suspicion is not enough. Political timing is not enough. Even losing a prosecution on appeal is not necessarily enough.


If we are going to accuse someone of deliberately using the justice system as a political weapon, prove it.


Six Cases That left six cases deserving deeper examination. They involve secret surveillance, tax administration, bank regulation, civil enforcement, a sweeping federal criminal investigation, and a state criminal prosecution of a former president.


I did not expect every case to produce the same answer. They did not.


In the Carter Page matter, the serious issue is not whether the entire Russia investigation was invented from nothing. It is what happened in the FISA process. In the IRS controversy, the question centers on viewpoint-sensitive administrative screening. Operation Choke Point asks whether informal regulatory pressure can become coercive even when regulators possess legitimate authority. Standard & Poor’s raises the possibility of retaliatory enforcement while also containing a substantial underlying government case.


Arctic Frost forces us to confront an especially difficult possibility: Can a criminal investigation begin with a legitimate predicate and later expand so broadly into one political movement that the investigative process itself becomes a lawfare concern?


And Manhattan asks another uncomfortable question: Can prosecutors possess real evidence and obtain guilty verdicts while the legal architecture and procedures surrounding the prosecution still raise serious questions about political use of prosecutorial power?


Facts First. Interpretation Second.


Throughout this series I will separate three things: what the record proves, what the evidence reasonably suggests, and what remains political interpretation. Those categories are not interchangeable.


Motive is harder than documenting what happened. Sometimes the evidence may strongly support an inference. Sometimes it will not. And sometimes the most honest sentence in the article will be:


We do not know.


That is not weakness. That is what happens when you follow the evidence instead of demanding that the evidence follow your politics.


Donald Trump Makes the Test Harder, Not Easier


Donald Trump inevitably sits near the center of some of this investigation. His supporters see years of investigations and prosecutions and conclude that the legal system was weaponized. His opponents see a politician repeatedly pushing legal boundaries and finally being held accountable.


Here is the possibility neither camp particularly likes: both can sometimes be right.


Trump can push aggressively against legal limits. A lawsuit against him can be legitimate. A prosecutor can possess real evidence. A court can properly rule against him. And another prosecutor, investigator or government official can still misuse legal power against him.


We do not have to pick one narrative and force every case into it. We have to examine each case.


What Happens When the Weapon Changes Hands?


Political power changes hands. A legal tactic applauded when it hurts the politician we despise does not disappear when our side loses the next election. The precedent remains. The investigative authority remains. The prosecutorial theory remains. The administrative power remains.


That is why conservatives should not define lawfare as “whatever prosecutors do to Republicans.” And progressives should not define justice as “whatever prosecutors can legally do to Donald Trump.” Neither standard survives a change in political power.


The only useful standard is one we are willing to apply when our own side is holding the weapon.


Now Let’s Test It


The next six installments will take these cases one at a time. Not the cable-news version. Not the Republican version. Not the Democratic version.


The record.


Some cases may reveal legitimate government action surrounded by partisan outrage. Others may reveal overreach without sufficient evidence of political punishment. And some may meet our Level 3 standard for strong process-centered lawfare concerns.


Then, in the eighth and final installment, we will put all six cases beside one another and ask the larger question: Are we watching America’s constitutional system struggle through an extraordinarily bitter political era, or are we watching legal power gradually become another weapon Americans use to defeat political opponents?


Maybe the answer is uncomfortable. Maybe it is some of both. But we are not going to decide the answer first and work backward. We are going to make the evidence earn the conclusion.


If you tell me it is lawfare: Prove it.


And if you tell me it is not: Prove that too.

Comments


Contact us!

Thanks for submitting!

2024 Revolver Broadcasting. All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page